Two words get used as if they meant the same thing, and they don’t. Sympathy is feeling sorry for someone. Empathy is feeling with them. The difference sounds small. In a relationship, it decides a lot.
Two different things
Sympathy looks at someone from a little distance and says, “That’s too bad.” It isn’t wrong. When a child is hurt, or someone is struck by something they had no part in, sympathy is a natural, decent response.
Empathy steps closer. It feels what the other person feels, from the inside. In Relational Mechanics, empathy sits at the center of how I define respect: “An empathy-driven process, where you use boundaries and standards to control your own ego.”
That definition says something people tend to miss. Respect needs empathy, but empathy alone isn’t respect. It also takes the strength to hold a boundary. Pleasers are a good example. They often have plenty of empathy. They just give it all away, and keep none to control their own ego. Book 1 puts it this way: “Real empathy runs both ways. If you’ve got deep empathy for other people, at least half of it needs to come back to you.”
The sympathy ratchet
When I was younger, I went through a stretch of feeling sorry for myself, and the relationship I was in at the time ended because of it. Looking back, I can see how the pattern worked, and I call it the sympathy ratchet.
It starts small. Something happens, you talk about it, and you get some attention. But it’s sympathy, not empathy, and that’s the problem. You get rewarded, just not with the right reward. It isn’t what people want to give you, and it isn’t what you need.
Because it worked a little, you turn it up a little. Pretty soon, instead of being strong to get attention and affection, you’re using sympathy to get it. People who used to be proud to be with you start to feel almost embarrassed.
There’s a window, and it closes fast. The more you want, the less they give. As they give you less, they start finding people who aren’t negative so much of the time. Now you’re getting less, so you wind it up more, and they pull back more, and around it goes.
Panhandling for emotional change
In Relational Mechanics, I described the emotional piggy bank. Good moments drop coins in, and those coins keep the ego cool. When you’re hurting, friends drop a little into your account, because that’s what people do. A donation here, a donation there.
But a friend isn’t invested in you the way a partner is. A month later they’ve put in a lot and you’re still broke, and their own ego steps back in to do its real job, which is protecting the person it belongs to. In plain words, they’re saying, I’ve given you enough. Your account with them has gone negative.
That’s what a pity party really is: standing on the corner with a sign, panhandling for emotional change. Sympathy feeds the ego. It doesn’t feed you.
Here’s why. Sympathy keeps the ego’s armor up and the focus on what was done to you. In a pity party there’s no self-respect, no boundaries, and empathy is shut out. As I put it, “You cannot have boundaries and be in a pity party.” And in a pity party, you’re only a taker. The positive is gone, and you have little left to give.
The research on reassurance points the same direction. Book 1 draws on Thomas Joiner’s work on excessive reassurance seeking: people who lack internal self-worth keep chasing validation from others to get temporary relief from their own anxiety.
Where empathy belongs
So what changes it? Not more sympathy. Book 1 calls the turn “turning empathy inward.” You take the empathy you’ve spent years pouring into other people and use some of it to steady your own ego and hold your own boundaries. That’s what self-respect is built on.
Turned inward, empathy also lets you see yourself honestly without tearing yourself down. Realistic self-assessment is respect. Disrespecting yourself takes you down and tends to drag other people with you.
And when empathy has a self to come back to, it can go out to other people as real connection, not as a trade for pity. That’s the kind of attention people are glad to give. Good people want to be around people who are getting back up.
It’s easier to get people to feel sorry for you than it is to pick yourself up and be strong. But only one of those builds anything that lasts.
This article is education, not treatment. If you are struggling with low mood or you are not safe, please reach out to a licensed counselor or your local emergency services.
The empathy and piggy bank ideas come from my first book, Relational Mechanics, available now. My second book, We Love What We Value: Why the Victim Can’t, and How Self-Respect Ends It, available now, tells more of that pity-party stretch and looks at sympathy as the first payoff of the victim mentality.
Leave a Reply